Harvard academic accused of calling for Palestinian ‘genocide’ 1, March 2010
Posted by thegulfblog.com in American ME Relations, Israeli-Palestinian Conflict.Tags: Genocide, Martin Kramer, palestine, Palestinian genocide, Pro natal subsidies
1 comment so far
There have been severe denunciations from across the political spectrum for remarks made by Martin Kramer, a Harvard based American-Jewish academic. He is charged with making comments tantamount to calling for what some describe as genocide of Palestinians in Gaza.
The crux of this speech is that Gaza’s population has risen significantly in recent years. This is partly due to ‘pro-natal’ subsidies given by the international community. This will lead to Gaza’s population doubling by 2030. This ‘excess’ of people means that life is cheap which, Kramer continues, fuels the culture of martyrdom that pervades Gaza. Ergo, if these ‘pro-natal’ subsidies are stopped by the international community, then this will slow population growth which will in turn begin to ‘drain the pond’ to borrow another neocon term.
Stephen Walt authored a superb retort to Kramer on his blog and concentrated on three points.
Firstly, he states that the 1948 UN definition of genocide includes “imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group.” Walt suggests that Kramer’s call to end such ‘pro-natal subsidies’ is “very close to that part of the definition” but that the term genocide in modern usage has much wider connotations and as such Kramer’s comments, whilst epically distasteful, probably ought not to be referred to as genocide.
Personally, I think that Walt is being rather kind when he refers to Kramer’s comments as being ‘very close’ to that aspect of the definition. For if controlling food supplies with a stated aim of slowing down birth rates does match that particular quote from the 1948 UN Genocide definition, nothing will. However, I agree with Walt’s conclusion that the term genocide has changed and evolved far beyond this aspect and carries with it far greater connotations today.
Secondly, Walt makes a devastating analogy. What if Ahmadinahad was fearful that Iran’s Jewish population was growing too quickly and he thus sought ways to discourage Iranian Jews from having children? Kramer et al would be falling over themselves to denounce the Iranian regime as genocidal. Or if a Harvard academic noted that higher crime rates among some black communities meant that somehow seeking to limit their food supplies would be a suitable anti-crime measure. Even Fox would have to come out against that…well…
Thirdly, Walt notes the bitter irony that Kramer can make these comments under the banner of ‘academic freedom’ and he is thus, or should be, protected. Yet it is exactly this banner that Kramer, Pipes et al seek to dismantle for those with whom they disagree.
Brazil friendy in Palestine, not Israel 21, June 2009
Posted by thegulfblog.com in Israeli-Palestinian Conflict.Tags: Angry Arab, Brazil, Corinthians, Flamengo, football, Israel, palestine, Ramallah
add a comment
Two Brazilian clubs are going to play a football friendly in Ramallah in the Palestinian Territories. However, the Israeli Ambassador is complaining that they are not going to go at all to Israel. As Abu Khalil, the Angry Arab says, it really is like the rich, unpopular kid in the class with no friends, moaning at the other kids to let him play. Such bahaviou is, it seems to me, quite undignified for an Ambassador.
L’archipel de Palestine orientale 24, April 2009
Posted by thegulfblog.com in Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, Middle East.Tags: isreal, map, palestine, Palestine Archipeligo
add a comment
This is another fantastic map taken from Strange Maps. As the Arabist says, water has replaced all the areas controlled by the Israelis such as roads and settlements. It vividly highlights if not the impossibility then at least the vast difficulties involved with establishing a cogent and workable state under such conditions.
Cartoons from the media 9, February 2008
Posted by thegulfblog.com in Random.Tags: al Hayat, cartoon, Gaza, Israel, palestine
add a comment
Al Hayat, London. 7.02.08
Cartoons from the media 7, February 2008
Posted by thegulfblog.com in Random.Tags: al watan, Cartoons, isreal, Middle East, palestine, saudi press, syrian press, tishreen
add a comment
The same caveat applies:
These cartoons are emphatically not meant as some kind of political statement on my behalf and neither are they here to offend. They are simply what I have come across on a day to day basis and thought others might find them amusing/thought provoking/telling/meaningful etc.
(Click to enlarge)
On Israel, Palestine and International Law.
Tishreen, Syria 29/01/08
The picture improves in Saudi Arabia.
Al Watan, Saudi Arabia 4.2.08
The Gulf blog 